Is HIPAA Compliance Enough, or Do I Need HITRUST?
What the law requires, what it leaves open, and when customers ask for more.
HIPAA is a federal law that sets minimum privacy and security rules for protected health information. It has no official certification. HITRUST is a certifiable framework that incorporates HIPAA alongside other standards, so you can show independent proof. For many organizations HIPAA compliance is required, and HITRUST is what customers ask for next.
What HIPAA requires, and what it leaves open
HIPAA applies to covered entities, such as providers and health plans, and to business associates, which are the vendors that handle protected health information on their behalf. The Security Rule requires administrative, physical and technical safeguards, including a documented risk analysis and a plan to manage the risks it finds.
The rule is deliberately flexible. It tells you what to protect, but it does not hand you a list of specific controls, and it does not name an assessor. Some implementation specifications are required and others are addressable, which means you can adopt an alternative if you document why.
There is also no government-issued HIPAA certification. When a vendor says it is “HIPAA certified,” that is a private claim, not an official designation. Enforcement happens through the HHS Office for Civil Rights, usually after a complaint or a breach.
What HITRUST adds
Defined controls
The HITRUST CSF turns broad rules into specific requirements, mapped to HIPAA, NIST and other standards.
Independent validation
An outside assessor tests your controls, and HITRUST reviews the results before issuing a certification.
A result customers can rely on
One certification letter can replace many individual security questionnaires.
One caution
HITRUST certification does not guarantee HIPAA compliance, and it does not prevent enforcement. It is strong evidence that your controls are in place and tested, not a legal safe harbor.
Three common misunderstandings
“HIPAA certified” is not an official status. If a vendor uses the phrase, ask what they mean. It usually describes their own program, not a government designation.
A HITRUST certification applies to a defined scope. It covers the systems and services that were assessed, so ask what is in scope before relying on the letter.
Passing an internal HIPAA review does not satisfy a HITRUST requirement. A customer who asks for HITRUST wants independent validation, and a self-assessment will not substitute.
What a customer means when they ask
When a health system or payer asks whether you are HITRUST certified, they are asking for independent proof that your controls work, in a form they do not have to evaluate themselves. Some customers accept other assurance reports or a completed questionnaire, and some name HITRUST in the contract. Ask which they will accept before you start any work.
HIPAA and HITRUST compared
| HIPAA | HITRUST | |
|---|---|---|
| What it is | Federal law | Certifiable security framework |
| Who requires it | Covered entities and business associates, by law | Usually customers, payers and partners, by contract |
| Certification | None offered | Yes: e1, i1 and r2 levels |
| Specific controls | Flexible and risk-based, few prescribed | Defined control requirements |
| Who verifies | Mostly self-attestation, with HHS investigating after a complaint or breach | External assessor plus HITRUST quality review |
| Scope of standards | Health information privacy and security | HIPAA plus NIST, ISO 27001 and others |
When HIPAA compliance alone is enough
If you are a smaller organization, your customers accept your own documentation, and nobody in your contracts names a framework, a well-documented HIPAA program may be all you need today.
When HITRUST becomes the better choice
- A health system, payer or large employer requires it in vendor contracts.
- You answer a steady flow of long security questionnaires and want to reduce them.
- You handle large volumes of protected health information.
- You need to show one set of evidence against several frameworks at once.
What this means for healthcare, finance and government
Covered entities must meet HIPAA directly. Their vendors increasingly need HITRUST to win and keep contracts.
HIPAA applies only where you handle health information, such as in insurance or benefits. Other financial regulations still apply, and HITRUST is one way to show your control environment to partners.
Agencies that administer health programs, and the contractors that support them, often need to show strong controls over health data. HITRUST evidence can support those reviews.
SmartBase Solutions has held HITRUST CSF r2 certification since 2017. We help healthcare, finance and government organizations understand where HIPAA ends and where a customer's expectations begin.
Wondering where your organization stands?
If a customer has asked about HITRUST, or you are not sure HIPAA compliance covers what they expect, talk it through with us before you commit to an assessment.
Get A Complimentary Evaluation